Tuesday, May 7, 2024

I&M Canal: Lock: #9 and #10 in Marseilles, IL

#9: (Satellite)
#10: (Satellite)

Illinois and Michigan Canal Photo Tour posted
Wonderful rendering of the canal at Lock 10, Marseilles. The grain elevator eventually burned to the ground.

1940 Marseilles Quad @ 62,500

These two locks are just a block apart. It makes sense that there is a steep gradient here because the Illinois river needs a canal and a lock to get around the rapids that were here. And that gradient is why there used to be a lot of water power mills in this town. 
Satellite



Monday, May 6, 2024

B&O Bridge over Black River near Lodi, OH

(Satellite)

There are no leafless street views available.
Street View, Jul 2014

4 of the 18 photos posted by Moses Zacharewicz with the comment: "Today [May 4, 2024] was the B&O Railroad Historical Society mini convention in Grafton OH.   It is a true pleasure to hear in person the stories of the railroad, some which have been passed down for generations.   I brought a few models along, including the B&O (CV&T) station in Cleveland, and a couple attendees told me stories how they used to work in the actual building."
Moses Zacharewicz shared
a
The Lodi Stone Viaduct over the Black River

b
Beautiful scene that is hard to see from the highway once the trees reach full bloom

c
Another view from below


d
The gate to this road was open this day, so I was able to get on the road that passes under the arch
John Carpenter: Originally the B&O intended to only erect 2 of the triple arch bridges.
They tried to force the Township to redirect the road under the western bridge and eliminate the middle bridge.
There was actually a riot, farmers and local residents were really pissed off.
There may or may not have been some gunfire. The residents tore out the work that had been done and forced the railroad to build the middle bridge.

Was this the second bridge that the B&O had planned to build?
Street View, Sep 2021 (Satellite)

And was this the third bridge that they were forced to build?
Street View, Mar 2023 (Satellite)

Sunday, May 5, 2024

1984 West Seattle Bridge closed March 23, 2020 for 2.5 years after just 36 years of service

(Archived Bridge HunterSatellite, the southern bridge)

The 2,607' (795m) long bridge has a main span of 590' (180m). [BridgeHunter]
It has a clearance of 157' (48m). [pauldorpat]

Street View, Jun 2019
[The Spokane Street Bridge, or Low Bridge, is in the background.]

Because it is a high-clearance bridge, it has long approaches.
Street View, Feb 2023

Until this bridge was built, the only access to the West Seattle peninsula from downtown Seattle was a drawbridge.
chron, License: Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) via Dennis DeBruler

Traffic was so bad on these bridges that "on March 29, 1978, a who’s who of West Seattle launched a campaign to secede from Seattle....A separate West Seattle would become the state’s fourth largest city, with stronger status to secure money for a high bridge to connect with top dog Seattle." But at 2:58am June 11, 1978, the succession effort wasn't needed because a freighter allided with the bridge. "The culprit was the now-legendary three-minute “lack of concentration” of 80-year-old pilot Rolf Neslund, who, bizarrely, later was murdered by his wife." The damage was considered irreparable. After decades of fighting, politicians then quickly found funding for the desired high bridge. [pauldorpat]

The Antonio Chavez freighter that ended the funding controversies for a high bridge.
seattlemet, COURTESY SEATTLE MUNICIPAL ARCHIVES / 73167,
"'His ship was able to do in a few seconds something the city hasn’t been able to do in years….he helped solve a problem that decades of official oratory, committee-forming and money-spending had only turned into a bigger problem.' —Ross Anderson, The Seattle Times, June 27, 1978"
I read that at one time the name of the bridge was the Jeanette Williams Memorial Bridge. This webpage explains that she was the Seattle council member that helped lobby for federal funds. Naming a bridge after a pork-barrel hero is a long-standing tradition for bridges. (e.g. Huey P Long bridges) I wonder why they decided to remove her name.

But there must have been 6 years of congestion on the remaining bridge because the High Bridge did not open until 1984. [BridgeHunter]

Just 36 years later, during the Covid-19 lockdown the bridge was closed for 2.5 years.
whereiamnow
"An inspection in 2014 revealed cracks in the bridge that might have been caused by the Nisqually Earthquake of 2001. (Or was it from a tendency to flutter in high winds?) The bridge was monitored regularly from then on. It was declared unsafe and closed suddenly on March 23, 2020. As of this writing, it's still closed and undergoing repair. Because of a concrete workers' strike, it is uncertain when repairs will be complete and the bridge reopened."

seattlemet, COURTESY CHUN KWAN / SDOT
"The West Seattle Bridge, officially opened in July 1984, closed in March 2020 after the discovery of cracked support girders, which make travel on the 36-year-old structure unsafe."

They discovered that the bridge could not even hold its own deadweight! They had to do stabilization work in 2020 even though they may later decide to tear the whole thing down. The stabilization work involved building work platforms, epoxy injection crack filling, carbon-fiber wrapping, external post tensioning inside the box girders and freeing the lateral bearing at Pier 18.
sdotblog_20200629

From this photo, I thought Pier 18 was on the west side, but from this report, it is on the east side. The plan was to fix that bearing and see if the cracks quit growing.
sdotblog_20200422

This diagram is worth noting because the C bearings show the location of the suspended span for this cantilever bridge. This webpage also has a diagram of the lateral bearing and a detailed explanation of what is wrong.
sdotblog_20200422

sdotblog_20200407
This is an animated gif that shows how the cracks started growing faster and faster.

The 8 months of stabilization effort became Phase I of a repair plan because in Nov 2020 they decided to repair the bridge. Fixing the Pier 18 bearing "helped the bridge find some major stress relief" when completed in Nov 2020
sdotblog_20210122

While Phase I was called stabilization, Phase II was called rehabilitation. It was basically doing to the side spans what was done to the central span and do more carbon-fiber wrapping of the central span.
seattle

They expect this repair to last until 2060. But they planned how to replace it anyhow in case they are wrong.
"Once repaired, the lifespan of the bridge is estimated to be between 15 to 45 years." The repairs of this bridge and the Low Bridge cost federal taxpayers $11.2m. [seattlepi]
That lifespan estimate range implies that they really don't know how long it will last.

Saturday, May 4, 2024

1917+1924+1991 Spokane Street Bridge over Duwamish Waterway in Seattle, WA

1917: (Archived Bridge Hunter) This was the third bridge built at this crossing.
1991: (Archived Bridge Hunter; Satellite, it is the northern bridge)
 
Bridges Now and Then posted
Seattle's Spokane Street Bridge, a double swing bridge, pretty neat, details in the comments. (Mark Yashinsky)
The bridge on the right is the Seattle West Bridge or High Bridge.

The two round piers are what allowed me to identify the swing spans.
Street View, Feb 2023

Unless you like the sound of the bell, skip to 1:00.
8:16 video @ 1:51
"It has a 480-foot (150 m) span....Each 7,500-short-ton (6,800 t) leaf of the bridge floats on a 100-inch (2.5 m) steel barrel in hydraulic oil. It is claimed to be the only bridge of its type in the world and it has received several awards for its innovation, including the Outstanding Engineering Achievement Award of the American Society of Civil Engineers in 1992."

I watch towboats handle barges, but not tugboats. Why is the barge dragging two chains?
@ 4:12
.

Repairs


The "Outstanding Engineering Achievement" seems to be a maintenance nightmare.

"As part of our proactive maintenance efforts, we carried out the initial phase of the Spokane St Swing Bridge Rehabilitation Program from 2020 to 2022. These efforts included injecting epoxy resin into existing cracks in the low bridge and adding carbon-fiber wrapping in several locations on both interior and exterior surfaces to strengthen the bridge." [sdotblog]

sdotblog_2023-09-25

It was closed three weeks starting Dec 23, 2022, to remove a cylinder for emergency repairs.
KOMOnews
"During the three-week closure, the department said crews removed a damaged 15,000-pound cylinder, repaired underground power conduit and replaced valves and hoses on the eastern bridge span’s hydraulic power unit." [In another article, SDOT says the cylinder weights 20,000 pounds.]

Here are SDOT's details about why it needed emergency repairs. The planned outage was for a week, but it ended up being three weeks.
The problem initially appeared to be associated with a computer issue that occurred while the bridge was powering back up after a power outage. Once the computer issue was resolved, engineers found previously identified minor issues with the hydraulic system that moves the bridge had intensified.

SDOT completes regular inspections of the Low Bridge and had existing plans to repair these aging components in 2023. However, after the power outage, it was discovered that previously manageable small-scale issues had escalated into more severe problems. Until these components are fixed, the bridge cannot be reliably moved without risking more severe long-term damage.

SDOT engineers are working as quickly as possible to analyze repair options. While there is not yet an estimate for how long bridge repair will take, SDOT expects the closure to last for at least two weeks.

Based on the evaluation results, additional Low Bridge closures for repairs may be needed in 2023, along with closures associated with planned capital improvements to the bridge next year.
One week in Oct 2023 to replace the cylinder.

One week of outage was planned starting Oct 7, 2024, to reinstall the overhauled cylinder and remove the second cylinder for refurbishment. 
mynorthwest, Photo from Seattle Department of Transportation
The bridge opens about four times a day.
They are confident that during the 3-week outage at the beginning of 2023 they learned how to remove and install a cylinder in 2-3 days per cylinder.

They learned their repair lesson well because the outage was just 3 days instead of the planned 7 days. 
SeattleBikeBlog, Image from SDOT
"The department did not say how crews achieved this early reopening, but perhaps they have gotten very good at fixing this odd pivoting bridge because it breaks down so often....More closures will be needed in the somewhat near future to repair the other cylinders and the control system, though dates have not yet been announced."

It closed Apr 19-28, 2024, for more maintenance.
yahoo and fox13seattle

The carbon-fiber wrap reinforcement is needed because cracks developed after just 3 decades of service. [kuow]

seattle
This webpage details the maintenance work for the 9-day Apr 2024 closure. 

This bridge is a violation of the KISS (Keep it Simple, Stupid) principle. I wonder how many multi-day outages were suffered by the Government and Fort Madison bridges after just a few decades.
.

1924


When built, the 1917 bridge was considered temporary with a lifespan of 10 years. This replacement bridge was the first one built with concrete and steel. [whereiamnow, a history of the bridges to West Seattle]

pauldorpat
"Rerouted westbound traffic clogs the 1930 West Seattle drawbridge during the afternoon rush hour of Monday, June 12, 1978, some 36 hours after the freighter Antonio Chavez rammed its companion 1924 span (right) and stuck it upward and beyond repair. (Greg Carter, West Seattle Herald, courtesy Robinson Newspapers)"
The first bridge was built in 1924, and the second one was added in 1930.
 
pauldorpat
"The 1924 span of the Spokane Street Bridge soon after the June 11, 1978, ramming stuck it open. The recently opened Kingdome is seen in the background. (Greg Carter, West Seattle Herald)"
West Seattle was organizing to succeed from Seattle so that they could get funds to build a replacement bridge. But a freight alliding with this bridge made succession unnecessary. [My notes on the High Bridge has more info about the allision.] It was replaced by the high bridge next to it. But in 1991, even the low bridge was replaced.

chron, License: Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY)
 
Flickr, May 1, 1930, via BridgeHunter_1924, License: Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY)
Seattle Municipal Archives
Traffic on West Spokane Street Bridge, 1930
Item 4051, Engineering Department Photographic Negatives (Record Series 2613-07), Seattle Municipal Archives.
.

1917


Douglas Butler via BridgeHunter_1917


Friday, May 3, 2024

US-50 Bridge over Gunnison River closed because of cracked steel girder

(Satellite)

There is no timeline as to when it may reopen.
1:52 video

The detour is six hours. [11:27 video @ 0:40] This is another bridge where T-1 steel has proven to be a booboo. It was used in bridges from 1959 to the 1970s. 64 bridges were built with T-1 steel.

Thursday, May 2, 2024

1930 CSX/(Lehigh Valley+Pennsy) Upper Bay Bridge over Newark Bay

(Bridge Hunter; no Historic Bridges; Satellite)

The predecessor bridge was a swing bridge built by Lehigh Valley in 1913.

Street View

It's always good to catch a train on a bridge because that means the route is still used.
Street View

Jonathan Konopka posted
This is the Upper Bay Bridge, which connects Newark, NJ and Bayonne, NJ. It is a vertical lift bridge that was built in 1930 and carries the CSX National Docks Branch over the Newark Bay.
James Kenney: AKA Lehigh Valley bridge.

EN via BridgeHunter

William Billson posted
Today [May 1, 2024] at 3pm Conrail Terminal Dispatcher assuming control of Upper Bay interlocking and Garden switches. The operators are staying at the bridge, but will be bridge tenders.
Ken Jamin: If the signals governing movement over the bridge clear automatically when the bridge is down and locked, the bridge centers are not under the HOS and can work indefinitely. However if the bridge tender has to line the signal manually, they are under DS HOS. (Nine hours in 24).
[I decided that HOS means Hours of Service.]
William Billson: Ken Jamin dispatcher handling signals and unlocks bridge for operator.

Wednesday, May 1, 2024

1927 Maine Central Carlton and 2000 US-1 Sagadahoc Bridges over Kennebec River at Bath, ME

Road: (Satellite)

Both BridgeHunter and HistoricBridges indicate that Maine Central is now owned by Main Eastern Railroad, but a USGS map labels the route as Maine Coast.

The upper deck of the old bridge used to carry US-1 until the new bridge was built. When the new one opened, they removed the road approaches from the old one. Obviously, the new bridge was built with concrete box girders.
Street View, Jun 2023

The new bridge cost $46.6m. [route1views]

C Hanchey via BridgeHunter

When closed, the lift span has a clearance of 10' (3m) and a width of 200' (61m). [WaterwayGuide]

MaineMemory
"The bridge that is named for Maine State Senator Frank W. Carlton was built to carry automobiles and trains across the Kennebec River between Bath and Woolwich."

Roger Williams added
View of the Carlton Bridge from the Sagadahoc Bridge. The vertical-lift bridge was built in 1927 and carried both automobile and freight train traffic between Bath and Woolwich Maine over the Kennebec River. In 2000 the Sagadahoc Bridge was built next to the Carlton Bridge for automobile traffic and the upper deck of the Carlton bridge closed. Trains continue to cross the Kennebec on the lower deck.

Roger Williams added

It appears that the lower deck of the lift span could handle vehicles as well as trains so that it could remain allow vehicle traffic when it was raised to a higher clearance. We have seen that with other lift bridges such as the Portage Bridge.
LoC

I'm surprised that I've seen so many photos with the span all the way down, but without a train on the lower deck. I would think it would only go down when a train wants to use it.
This shows that the lower deck still has two tracks. I wonder how the bridge inspectors got a pickup truck and worker lift on the upper deck since the approach spans have been removed.
Street View, Oct 2016

The two most recent street views caught the span in its partially opened position. My first thought was that since the upper deck is no longer used, the span could be left open all the way. But then I realized that there are probably no longer any big boats using the river so saving wear and tear on the lift equipment makes sense.
Street View, Aug 2023

Street View, Aug 2018