West Portal of Pennsy Sabula Tunnel: (
Satellite, one of the photos is of the southern tunnel.)
I was very confused for a long time as to which tunnel was which. Finally, I figured out that most of the sources make sense if the Upper Tunnel was the southern one and the Lower tunnel was the northern one. A lot of sources pointed out that there was a second tunnel nearby, but they used terms like "next to," "close by," etc. No one used terms like "north of" or "south of." If you know which is which, please comment. I'm writing these notes with the working assumption that the
Buffalo & Susquehanna Tunnel was the Upper Tunnel, but south of, the Pennsy Tunnel. And this confusion about Upper is South while Lower is North is why I use the labels of Pennsy and B&O instead of Upper and Lower in the remaining text.
 |
| 1929/1954 Penfield Quad @ 62,500 |
1905 Pennsy (Northern) Tunnel
If you know which portal is which (east vs. west), please comment.
1874 Bats/Aban/B&O/BR&P/B&S (Southern) Tunnel
Most of the sources imply that this is the Upper Sabula Tunnel. It is now sealed off as a bat sanctuary.
This was posted Oct 13, 2020, before it was turned into a bat shelter.
As is typical of abandoned tunnels, some of comments on the Facebook posts talk about the ghosts they have seen in the tunnel.
Connie Woods
posted six photos with the comment:
Upper Sabula tunnel
The Buffalo & Susquehanna, c.1905, cut through the second tunnel. The “Hoodlebug” and other passenger trains ran from the Sabula station through DuBois to Punxsutawney. Workers used the tunnel material to build the dam in the early 1870’s.
The first tunnel is still in use. To get to the second tunnel, you need to walk through the first tunnel.
 |
| 1 |
 |
| 2 |
 |
| 3 |
 |
| 4 |
 |
| 5 |
 |
| 6 |
Some comments confirmed that this tunnel has a slight S-curve.
Forgotten Clearfield County PA
posted three photos with the comment: "Upper Sabula Train tunnel near Dubois. I did not go personally (yet)."
 |
| 1 |
 |
| 2 |
 |
| 3 |
 |
AlleghenyFront The tunnel was gated in 2017 to protect the bats, some of which are endangered. |
Both
1870s “Old” Sabula Tunnel 1,040’ - Built by Allegheny Valley Railroad 🚂
Sabula, PA
Clearfield County
Her video starts with the southern tunnel. Later, she walks over to the northern tunnel and explains that it was built in 1905. However, she says it was built by the
Buffalo & Susquehanna. So I think she is also confused about the identity of the two tunnels.